With that in mind, I thought now was as good a time as any to take a look at the last three and a bit seasons and pick out some of the best games we've enjoyed under Chris Wilder's stewardship. I had to cut out some good results, big away days and major upsets to curate this top ten, which shows how good we've had it since summer 2016. Here's ten great games to make you miss football even more than you already are:
10: Northampton (H) 2016
This is a bit of an editor’s choice. The last fixture of 2016 saw Chris Wilder come up against his former club, and climb to the summit of League 1 for the first time. A crisp New Year’s Eve in Sheffield had us celebrating more than the arrival of 2017 after this victory. This game was at the latter end of an extraordinary run of 21 league matches in which The Blades only lost once. This time they could just manage a single goal in the 89th minute, the 1-0 scoreline hiding the dominance Sheffield United enjoyed in that game.
The first four games of the season had left us rock bottom on a single point, which is why it felt so monumental when we finally made it to the top. Sheffield United would stay there for the rest of the season, and despite a couple of blips here and there, entirely dominated the league in the way we’d hoped to see since relegation five years before. This game was important as it signalled the end of the first stage of the Wilder and Knill Project. It was the symbolic end to the struggle. We had built the solid base on which to mount our title push.
9: Manchester United (H) 2019
![]() |
| Lys Mousset here, pictured shortly after murdering Phil Jones. |
Promotion to the Premier League has many exciting prospects for fans, but one thing I was particularly interested in was how we’d fare against the big teams. Would playing against world-class stars like Sergio Aguero, Mo Salah and Harry Kane be too much for our lower league mercenaries? As it stands, we’ve had a respectable record against the Big Six so far, and haven’t yet compromised the attractive attacking imprint of football Wilder and Knill have stamped on the club’s psyche.
This was one of the most entertaining fixtures we’ve participated in this season, described as a topsy-turvy game by the press. In fact it was defined by seven minutes just after the hour mark, where Manchester United punished us with three goals to stun the stadium, and overturn the handsome lead The Blades had given themselves. Oli McBurnie’s late equaliser was all we deserved after fighting so hard.
The best I’ve felt all season so far was on 52 minutes, when Lys Mousset latched on to Fleck’s through ball and produced a clinical finish from just outside the area to beat David De Gea, and send Sheffield United 2-0 up. This was an incredible moment - We were leading at home to one of the biggest clubs in the world, and we were running the game. That was the peak of our early season; it was the game where English football sat up and took notice of what’s happening in Sheffield. A special night to remember under the lights at Bramall Lane.
8: Aston Villa (H) 2018
This one’s another personal favourite of mine, during that irresistible period at the start of last season where the Blades were flying through their home fixtures. Villa eventually got promoted of course, after a surge up the table got them to the play-offs. But at this time, they were flirting with relegation, and Sheffield United were merciless in their dismantling of Steve Bruce’s side.
This was Sheffield United’s fourth successive league victory, and with four different scorers drawn from all positions on the field, this was an exemplary win for Wilder and Knill’s focus on teamwork. No position is more important than another in their system, and to win games, the first XI need to operate as a unit. Sheffield United were truthfully out of sight at half time, but the pick of the goals was Sharp’s wicked half-overhead finish just after the restart. Villa rarely threatened, and their consolation on the hour mark brought an ironic “We’re gonna win 5-4” chant from the away end.
Six games into the season, to have such a well-established side as Aston Villa so roundly beaten was a luxury. It was a sign of things to come, a show of what this team was capable of at full stretch. In a season of great accomplishments, this still stands out as one of the top victories.
7: Bournemouth (A) 2019
The first game in the top flight. All summer we’d waited for the fixture list, and when this got confirmed it was arguably the best start we could hope for - Away at a mid table side, with a small stadium on the south coast. A seaside trip in August for barely 1,000 supporters. An exclusive feel it must have been to anyone in the away end that day.
In truth it was an average game, but for that one great moment. Billy Sharp, our club captain and talismanic driving force throughout this era found himself with an inch of space in the box. He struck it like you’d expect; quickly, with little grace and from about five yards out. A quintessential Sharp goal. He’d been on the pitch for six minutes, but had already left his mark on the game. The fans were beside themselves as he ran towards them, the rest of the squad flanking him in a show of joy and togetherness. Sheffield United were back.
6: Peterborough (A) 2017
This will have lots of people smiling at just the sound of those two words. Peterborough away. Even if you don’t say which year, everyone knows which game you mean. It’s already renowned in Blades folklore. Coming in the final third of the season, this win put us five points clear at the top of the table.
I suppose what makes this such a fond memory is that it was the first game where we started to accept that we could actually get promoted. After so many disappointing non-starters and false dawns, no-one wanted to jinx what was happening. But after this win away at a tough side, the tide of opinion started to shift. We allowed ourselves to start believing.
The Blades had pushed and fought all game, squandering a handful of chances. It took Sharp’s late goal for the result to be sealed, bringing a tidal wave of ecstasy from the travelling fans, (and a couple of stragglers onto the pitch). Billy had scored the goal right in front of the away end, and wheeled towards the heaving mass of supporters who, five minutes beforehand, will have thought the game was going to fizzle out. Not so, for Wilder’s never say die Sheffield United team. As with many games that season, we fought to the end, and received our deserved victory, even if it did take until the 87th minute!
5: MK Dons (A) 2017
![]() |
| Just a few beers with the lads, nothing too mad. |
This was the peak of the end-season rampage we enjoyed after promotion was secured. When you have a season like this, finishing 14 points clear of 2nd and getting promoted with four games to spare, it’s something special. Those final fixtures are a parade of glory, they are consequence-free pageants of life and colour. This game was pure celebration, with nothing at stake whatsoever. You could say the same about every game near the end of that season. We were truly spoiled in April 2017.
In the League 1 years, I’d make a point of looking for the final away fixture. Thinking, if we get promoted, that’s where it could happen. There could not have been a better venue for this than Stadium:MK, even if that name looks like a crappy deodorant brand from the 90s. 7,000 Sheffield United fans made the trip to Buckinghamshire, and the atmosphere was incredible. Because it was a new stadium, fairly large, and south of Sheffield, this felt similar to a Wembley trip. But unlike those play-off losses or semi-final disappointments, we knew we’d already won. With balloons floating up to the heavens, beach balls being thrown around and flags everywhere, the away end was one big party for two hours.
Top that off with the anarchic half time shenanigans in the concourse, and this was a memorable day for all involved. The Blades were invincible on the pitch that afternoon. They won the game 3-0, but that was by-the-by, an academic curio in the grand scheme of things. The league title and promotion had been sewn up by then. Psychologically the players were on another planet with the confidence they must have felt that day, and victory was the safest bet all season.
4: Leeds United (A) 2019
![]() |
| Look at those gutted Leeds players in the background. Lovely stuff. |
If there’s one thing you can guarantee with Wilder, it’s that he’ll always turn up for the big derby games. He has an unbeaten record against Wednesday (more on that later) and already has defeated Leeds United three times. Though all three of these victories were important ones, the most recent is also the most special. While this game didn’t decide anything, it was a watershed moment for the season. It was the first time many of us started to believe that Sheffield United would go up from The Championship at the second time of asking.
We all know how this goes, don’t we? With little flair but plenty of passion on the pitch, this was a game for the fans, and not for the casual observer. A robust, defensive performance kept the hosts at bay, and even though they pushed to find an opener, it was goalless at the break. You may have forgotten that Basham was playing further forward than he would do usually, occupying a midfield position that would prove critical. When Billy Sharp pounced on the ball and charged into a break, the former Newcastle man found himself running up the pitch alongside him, (“Basham’s arriving!”) and before we knew it, he had the ball just outside the box and was staring down the keeper.
Have you ever seen Chris Basham in that position before or since? Nevermind. Ping. He hit it first time and burst the back of the net, falling over in the process. The away end exploded as he ran to celebrate in front of the crowd, sliding on his belly to top off one of the most cherished goals of the Wilder era. That result was Sheffield United’s 7th clean sheet in a row, and meant they leapfrogged Leeds into 2nd. After the game Wilder made the observation that they played badly but still managed to win. That’s what was important about this game - Wilder’s Blades showed they can win ugly.
3: Ipswich (H) 2019
This game could have been irrelevant if things hadn’t turned out right for us. A couple of weeks before, we’d drawn at home to Millwall, which had us three points behind Leeds United with four games remaining. It looked like the cursed play-offs again, until a dramatic capitulation from our rivals over the Easter weekend saw a overturn in fortunes. All of a sudden, there it was - We went into this game knowing that a victory would all but hand Sheffield United automatic promotion to the Premier League.
A 5.30pm Saturday TV slot ensured that the crowd was hyped, and the eyes of the world would be watching Sheffield United take a giant leap towards returning to the top flight for the first time in 12 years. Scott Hogan put The Blades ahead in the first half, but it was Jack O’Connell who stole the show, putting the result out of sight with a powerful header, seconds after coming on the pitch and running on to meet an inswinging corner. Bramall Lane rocked as the home fans rose to their feet with the loudest and longest chorus of Jack O’Connell’s Magic, casting off the shackles of doubt and accepting that the dream had come true. Two promotions in three seasons? If you insist, Mr Wilder.
Sheffield buzzed all the night through, the party spanning out for hours and bumping up against the dawn. There was unfinished business the following afternoon, and many sore heads ventured to the pub to watch Leeds fail to beat Aston Villa and confirm the virtual certainty from the day before. Pints were raised, corks were popped, and hands were shook. The Blades were back in the big time.
2: Northampton (A) 2017
![]() |
| A legendary shot! |
What a bright, sunny afternoon for a game of football. This lager-soaked, full-throated day of joy, relief and glory. It’s Fleck bundling home on 88 minutes, it’s the triple pitch invasion, it’s Sharp being carried along, scarf aloft and victorious. The years of setbacks, the hard work of the season, the disappointments that had come so many times before, they were all worth it for this triumph. Sheffield United would have been promoted that day even if they lost 5-0, but the fightback from 1-0 down to win it in the last few minutes gave us something to shout about. If results had gone our way we’d have been promoted at home a few days before - But to clinch it on an away day Saturday made more sense. It was this generation’s Leicester City or Darlington.
The team coach pulled in to Bramall Lane a few hours after the game, with Wilder, already half drunk and jubilant, leading the chants in the car park with the throng of supporters that greeted the team’s arrival. London Road had been at a standstill since the result, with many Blades fans staying in the city to watch the game from the beamback finding a place to celebrate a stone’s throw from the stadium. The memories, though only three years old are already hazy, and outshone by some bigger results. But it’s my hope that no matter how far we go under Wilder, that you all don’t forget how it felt that day.
This was the pinnacle of the season. Though the title was confirmed a few games later, it had nowhere near the This Is A Moment To Savour sheen to it. We announced our League 1 title as a footnote, but our promotion to the 2nd tier came as a volcanic eruption. If you were one of the proud few in the away end, or camped on that little hill that overlooks Sixfields, I hope you soaked it all in. I hope you cheered as Chris Wilder conducted a speech from the dugout. I hope you slapped the lads on the back as they escaped down the tunnel. These are the thrills we buy into the culture for, so we can look back with nostalgic eyes and say “Yeah. Reight day that, wont it!”
1: Sheffield Wednesday (A) 2017
![]() |
| How many times have you watched this goal? |
Could it be any other game? How many wonderful memories we have from a Sunday afternoon already etched into Blades history. It was the derby victory of a generation, the statement to confirm United’s supremacy as the biggest team in Sheffield. It was 90 minutes of elation, with so many great moments to enjoy. 2-0 up after 15 minutes? A luxury final goal to seal it? That shot of the owl mascots looking sad? What a day. But it all boils down to a couple of minutes in the 2nd half...
Mark Duffy’s goal. From initially setting up the play, to the double shimmy on the defender to get some space and the acute-angled strike, (giving Danny Higginbotham the chance to bring out that well-worn commentary trope - “He’s got no right to score from there!”) it was a technically brilliant goal. But to ignore the context is criminal. Wednesday had it tied up to 2-2. They had come back, and were in the ascendancy. Their fans were doing that daft bouncing nonsense they do. They held their joy for a slender few grains of sand through the hourglass, and then it came. Washing over Hillsborough with silence, with dejection, all apart from the sonic boom from the Leppings Lane end. Euphoria beyond measure - It’s what we love the game for. Mark Duffy. Bounce Killer. He’ll never need to pay for a pint on London Road as long as he lives.
The list of iconic moments in this game make for good reading - This is the match that gave us Fleck’s early free-kick trickery, Leon Clarke bagging a brace, little Davey Brooks running riot on his 2nd professional start. That’s what made this game so important. It’s not just that we beat them, at their place, newly promoted after a five year absence. It’s the fact that we thrashed them. The players knew what it meant, that Wilder needed his resounding victory against Them Lot to be a true legend of the Lane. And so it was. Made all the sweeter due to the 0-0 bore-draws that followed. Our best game in decades, brought to us by our finest ever manager.
















